Court Rejects Expanded Mental Illness Limitation to Coverage
In Jarillo v. Reliance Standard Life Ins. Co., Judge Michael M. Anello of the United States District Court of the Southern District of California held that plaintiff Marife Jarillo met her burden of proof and was entitled to benefits under the ERISA. For about eight years, Jarillo worked in the marketing department of the Sycuan Band of The Kumeyaay Nation (a federally recognized Native American tribe located near San Diego). In 2010, Jarillo injured her back at work while attempting to lift a heavy box.
After the injury, Jarillo experienced progressively worsening back pain. She was diagnosed with lumbar radiculitis by a spinal surgeon following an MRI. Treatment attempts and physical therapy failed to improve her condition. As a result, Jarillo also began to experience severe depression and anxiety. Eventually, she was also diagnosed with chronic pain syndrome, anxiety and depression.
Jarillo submitted a claim to Reliance Standard Life Insurance for long-term disability benefits shortly after the injury. Reliance approved her claim of being “totally disabled” and began paying her long-term disability benefits each month. But in 2015, Reliance terminated these benefits, claiming that her anxiety and depression triggered the insurance plan’s mental illness coverage limitation, and that a new IME report showed that she could work. Jarillo appealed this decision, but Reliance upheld it.
The Mental Illness Limitation
Like most disability insurance policies, the Reliance group’s LTD Plan limited benefits for disabilities caused by a mental illness or disorder. According to the plan:
Monthly Benefits for Total Disability caused by or contributed to by mental or nervous disorders will not be payable beyond an aggregate lifetime maximum duration of twenty-four (24) months unless the Insured is in a Hospital or Institution at the end of the twenty-four (24) month period.
The Lawsuit
This case presented two main issues:
1) Whether the mental illness limitation applied; and
2) Whether Jarillo was “totally disabled.”
Judge Anello determined that the cause of Jarillo’s disability was her back injury. Although her anxiety and depression may have worsened her condition, these were merely symptoms of her physical injury. Moreover, Jarillo was never formally diagnosed with a mental disorder by a psychiatrist. Additionally, the court also noted that “the Plan is ambiguous as to how the limitation applies when both a physical and mental condition contribute to a disability.” Following common legal doctrine, the court held that in cases where an insurance plan is drafted ambiguously, the court should find an interpretation favorable to the non-drafter of the plan (ie, the insured). For all of these reasons, the court held that the mental illness limitation to coverage did not apply.
On the second issue, the court also agreed with Jarillo. The IME report cited by Reliance stated that Jarillo was able to perform “full duty at a light work level,” and video surveillance footage that showed Jarillo was able to walk without a cane. However, another doctor reported that when it came to light work, “she would be unable to maintain this for several consecutive hours, and she would be unable to tolerate repeating this each day during a work week.” Other medical evidence, including a Functional Capacity Evaluation, supported a finding of total disability. The court found that the IME and other evidence relied on by Reliance was insufficient to overcome the weight of evidence pointing to her full disability.
This case was not handled by our office, but we think it can be beneficial to those struggling to obtain long-term disability benefits. If you have any questions about your own disability claim, contact one of our attorneys at Dell & Schaefer for a free case evaluation.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Submit a Strong Reliance Standard Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Reliance Standard appeal.
Sue Reliance Standard
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Reliance Standard.
Get Your Reliance Standard Disability Application Approved
Prevent a Reliance Standard Disability Benefit Denial
Negotiate a Reliance Standard Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Policy Holder Rating
Short Term Disability Claim/Inconsistent to NO Communication
Staff Lie
Reply
Reliance Standard denied my LTD benefits because COVID-19 limited my ability to provide proof of continued disability.
Reply
Reliance Standard cut off my LTD benefits claiming I'm fit enough to work even though I'm more sick than before.
Reply
Reliance Standard notified me that my benefits were being stopped with no warning or reason.
Reply
I was receiving LTD from Reliance Standard due to breast cancer until they suddenly denied me my benefits.
Reply
Reliance Standard never answers or returns my calls, has not provided me my benefits, and falsely claims I never provided necessary paperwork.
Reply
Reliance Standard is unreasonably prolonging the transition from STD to LTD for my boyfriend.
Reply
Q: Are VA disability payments considered “other income” by Reliance Standard?
Q: Denied short term disability and need to file for long term with same insurer
Q: Will Reliance Standard reduce my LTD payments due to my pension benefits or rental income?
Q: Why is Reliance Standard trying to recover payments I was awarded through another company?
Q: Do I have to provide additional proof of my disability that's specifically requested by Reliance Standard?
Q: How do I access a copy of my STD policy with Reliance Standard?
Q: If I'm not receiving the SSDI benefits for my children from Reliance Standard due to custody, should my SSDI benefits increase?
Q: How can Reliance Standard not coordinate with both of my disability insurance policies?
How to Apply for Reliance Standard Disability Benefits & Top 5 Reasons for a Claim Denial
Why Must Your Disability Insurance Lawyer Understand Your Disabling Condition?
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #5 – Your Medical Evidence is Weak
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #4 - Your Doctor Is Misled By the Disability Company
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #3 - Video & Social Media Surveillance
How Do You Fight a Long-Term Disability Denial?
Disability Denial Reason #2 - Change of Disability Definition & Vocational Review
Disability Denial Reason #1 – Paper Review & IME
How does Reliance Standard deny long term disability benefits after paying for three years?
Reliance Standard overturned its previous denial of long term disability benefits for Texas Retail Store Manager
Reliance Standard overturned LTD denial for Tennessee Technology Sales Consultant
Reliance Standard overturns decision to deny long-term disability benefits to Paediatrician with Ovarian Cancer
Reliance Standard reinstates disability benefits to Project Manager
Reliance Standard Reinstates Benefits for Former Employee of Parent Company, Delphi Financial, Following Successful Appeal
Reliance Standard Overturns Denial of Benefits on Appeal After Claiming It Failed to Receive Medical Records
After sending claimant to a psychiatric IME, Reliance Standard realizes its decision to deny benefits was incorrect
Reviews from Our Clients






