United of Omaha criticized for relying on in-house medical review and failing to obtain independent examinations
This case was decided by a district court in Illinois and involved United of Omaha Life Insurance Company. An ERISA action was filed by the Plaintiff, Gina Tassone, after her LTD benefits were terminated. She had been paid two-years of regular-occupation benefits for her inability to work as a Finance Manager and like many group disability policies, her insurance policy’s definition of disability changed after two-years of benefits.
During its two-year review, United of Omaha relied on the opinions of two in-house clinical experts who reviewed the medical records, neither of whom ever examined Ms. Tassone. First, an in-house nurse opined that “it would be reasonable to expect Ms. Tassone to be able to sit for 6 hours out of an 8 hour day, lifting no more than 10 pounds occasionally with possible frequent lifting of small objects.”
Next, Dr. Reeder, United of Omaha’s medical director, provided a long list of reasons as to why Ms. Tassone’s medical records were deficient. Interestingly, Ms. Tassone’s file consisted of over 5,400 pages of medical records.
Following his review, Dr. Reeder sent letters to a number of Ms. Tassone’s treating doctors, asking them to respond to his conclusions, including a clarification regarding their treatment and restrictions and limitations. Each of Dr. Reeder’s letters indicated that if he did not get a response within 10 days, he would assume that the recipient was in agreement with his conclusions that Ms. Tassone was able to perform at the sedentary level.
None of the plaintiff’s treating doctors responded to the medical director’s challenge.
United of Omaha argued that by failing to disagree, those treating doctors tacitly agreed. The court disagreed pointing out that the letters were obviously written in a manner designed to lure the recipient into either agreeing with the medical director’s limited and biased review of the records or enter into a war of diagnoses with him. There is no upside for any doctor to engage in a dispute with an in-house physician so the court placed no significance on the doctor’ silence to such a biased letter.
The court placed little weight on the in-house nurse and doctor’s opinions, finding them undoubtedly biased given that both work for the defendant.
The court also pointed out that in-house medical director had been criticized in a similar case for ignoring conditions that cause pain despite the fact that it is the plaintiff’s extreme pain that supports her claim for LTD benefits.
Ms. Tassone was given a fee award and an award of prejudgment interest following the court’s finding that Ms. Tassone was unable to work full time at a sedentary position.
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Submit a Strong Mutual of Omaha Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Mutual of Omaha appeal.
Sue Mutual of Omaha
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Mutual of Omaha.
Get Your Mutual of Omaha Disability Application Approved
Prevent a Mutual of Omaha Disability Benefit Denial
Negotiate a Mutual of Omaha Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Policy Holder Rating
I do not understand how a “medical review team” who has never laid eyes on my wife can say she is able to return to work when her doctors who see her on a regular basis have documented that she can't
Reply
THEY SCAMMED ME AND DID NOT CARE
This company is awful
I would encourage anyone who has problems with Mutual of Omaha or United of Omaha to immediately contact an attorney.
MOO attempted to strong arms me with collection tactics. Now, they're stalling
MOO stopped my husband's benefits before telling him. They handled his claim terribly
Reply
This company is very corrupt, Be aware
Mutual of Omaha is a rip off.
Q: Can I ask for another appeal?
Q: I'm in jeopardy of losing everything because of MOO. Can you help?
Q: Can MOO deny my claim on the basis of preexisting condition when my condition is not preexisting?
Q: What is my "regular occupation" if I started my own business after resigning from my old job?
Q: Am I able to work part time at a different job that is nothing like the one I was at when I was injured?
Q: Can I get a lump sum check from MOO?
Q: Should I be able to restrict the release of medical records to under 24 months period?
Q: Should I write an appeal letter? What should it include?
What is a "Gainful Occupation" under a Disability Insurance Policy?
Can my insurance carrier deny my benefits even if there is no change in my medical condition?
Why Must Your Disability Insurance Lawyer Understand Your Disabling Condition?
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #5 – Your Medical Evidence is Weak
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #4 - Your Doctor Is Misled By the Disability Company
Disability Benefit Denial Reason #3 - Video & Social Media Surveillance
How Do You Fight a Long-Term Disability Denial?
Disability Denial Reason #2 - Change of Disability Definition & Vocational Review
After appeal filed by Attorney Jay Symonds, Mutual of Omaha overturned previous denial of short term disability benefits for Maine Senior Software Engineer
After an appeal, a former Director of Information Security, gets disability benefits approved for mental health disorder. The fight for long term disability benefits for client’s physical limitations continues
United of Omaha overturns decision to deny benefits to disabled Quality Assurance Manager after Appeal discredits its medical review and vocational assessment
After appeal filed by Attorney Jay Symonds, Mutual of Omaha overturned its previous denial of short term disability benefits for Colorado Senior Manager
Mutual of Omaha Reinstates Benefits of Business Development Manager after Appealing the Termination of Her LTD Benefits
Dell Disability Lawyers Successfully Appeals Denial of Benefits to Quality Control Inspector
Mutual of Omaha Approves Dell Disability Lawyers Client for Short Term Disability Benefits After Administrative Appeal
Mutual Of Omaha Overturns Denial of Short Term Disability Benefits for Software Developer With Chronic Back Pain
Reviews from Our Clients






