Dentist wins right to apply stricter standard of review in her case against Hartford for a claim for long-term disability benefits
(Group / ERISA Disability Policy) Carol Post, a dentist working at a hospital in New Jersey, was involved in a car accident in November 1993. Despite her whiplash injuries, she returned to work as a dentist, but was forced to stop working as a dentist because of her severe pain. She attempted in December 1993 to return to work as a pharmacist, since she also held a pharmacy degree. Ms. Post worked for nine months as a pharmacist and then was forced to stop working in September 1994 due to continued pain. During the period when she worked as a pharmacist, she averaged nearly a day per week that she was unable to work because of the pain. Ms. Post tried numerous physical therapy treatments that did not significantly improve her condition before attempting to return to work again in January 1995. Unfortunately she was forced to stop working once again in May 1995, because of her continued pain.
Evidence of Ms. Post’s treatment included records from 14 doctors over 10 years, beginning in 1993 following her accident. The treatments for her pain included:
- prescription drugs;
- trigger-point injections;
- physical therapy;
- acupuncture; and,
- biofeedback.
None of these treatments provided significant relief to her pain. Her neurologist, a professor at Columbia University, opined that her numerous medical conditions, such as severe myofascial pain, chronic debilitating headaches, sensitivity to light, nausea, vomiting, and irritable bowel syndrome, and insomnia were caused by her car accident and rendered Ms. Post totally disabled. Hartford paid total disability benefits from 1995 until 2002, and Ms. Post was approved for Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) benefits on August 7, 1998.
After paying Ms. Post disability benefits for seven years, Hartford abruptly terminated her benefits in January 2002, following a review of her file by Hartford’s medical director, in which Hartford’s doctor concluded that Ms. Post was not totally disabled. After exhausting her administrative remedies by filing two appelas, Ms. Post then filed suit for her disability benefits, but the trial court entered judgment against her, agreeing with Hartford’s argument.
Hartford argued that the medical records revealed Ms. Post had only a whiplash injury, relying mostly on the medical records review performed by its own physician and an independent medical examination. Hartford also based their denial on feedback from doctors who treated Ms. Post in 1994 and 1996, on forms prepared by Hartford that did not allow these treating physicians to indicate that Ms. Post was totally unable to work.
On appeal, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals, in Philadelphia disagreed with the trial court, noting that the District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania had not properly considered that:
- Hartford’s denial was largely based on the review of Ms. Post’s medical records by its own physician;
- That Ms. Post had received a fully favorable decision on her SSDI claim; and,
- That Hartford aggressively used disability surveillance in an attempt to show that Ms. Post was not disabled.
Individually, each of these items was not enough to show that Hartford might have acted improperly in cutting of Ms. Post’s disability benefits. However, the Appellate Court ruled that based on the totality of all the carrier’s actions, the lower court could have found in favor of Ms. Post.
As a practical note, the lower court will have to reconsider their previous decision and re-evaluate Ms. Post’s case. There is no guarantee that Ms. Post will receive benefits even as the trial court looks at the evidence a second time, but at least Ms. Post will be given a second chance.
See Post v. Hartford Ins. Co., 501 F. 3d 154 (3d Cir. 2007).
Resources to Help You Win Disability Benefits
Submit a Strong Hartford Appeal Package
We work with you, your doctors, and other experts to submit a very strong Hartford appeal.
Sue Hartford
We have filed thousands of disability denial lawsuits in federal Courts nationwide against Hartford.
Get Your Hartford Disability Application Approved
Prevent a Hartford Disability Benefit Denial
Negotiate a Hartford Lump-Sum Settlement
Our goal is to negotiate the highest possible buyout of your long-term disability policy.
Policy Holder Rating
Truly Horrible and Immoral Company with No Customer Service
Sent my Direct Deposit to a Strangers Bank Acct
Former Hartford employee has had life insurance and accidental death policy's revoked for one late premium payment
Reply
Bad Faith
Denied by Hartford after 20 years of Payments
This company is a scam!
Hartford Stopped Payments
Q: Can the Hartford collect short term disability payments that they say were due to their own mistakes?
Q: Are insurance companies allowed to deny payment of short term disability benefits because I am collecting social security retirement benefits disability?
Q: Does Hartford reduce their monthly LTD payments after 30 months?
Q: Can The Hartford offset my LTD on my VA disability compensation or back pay?
Q: Can Hartford lower my long term disability check if I take my money out of my Vanguard account?
Q: Relocation
Q: Is it possible to write me a strict authorization form for The Hartford?
Q: Denied by Hartford for Long-Term Disability Benefits
Does Hartford Pay Disability Insurance Claims?
How Does Hartford Long Term Disability Work?
What Happens If My Hartford Short Term Disability Claim is Denied?
How Long Does a Hartford Short Term or Long Term Disability Claim Last?
If I Convert my Former Employee Disability Policy to a Private Policy Does ERISA Govern?
Is the Hartford Disability Purchase of Aetna Bad for Aetna LTD Policy Holders?
Hartford Disability Claim Problems
How Can I Protect Myself At A Hartford IME Exam?
Nurse With Knee and Back Disorder Wins Hartford Disability Appeal
Executive Director with Meniere's Denied Long Term Disability Insurance Benefits By Hartford
A Hartford Disability Benefit Lawsuit Victory for Truist Banker with Lupus
Hartford Denies Disability Benefits To Home Depot Employee 3 Weeks Before Change of Disability Definition
Hartford Denies Long Term Disability Benefits After Paying for 22 Years
Hartford Overturns Denial of Disability Benefits on Appeal
Hartford Approves Disability Claim After Appeal Deadline
Hartford overturned its previous denial of LTD benefits for Illinois Account Representative
Reviews from Our Clients






